[mkgmap-dev] Error in MdrCheck?
From Gerd Petermann gpetermann_muenchen at hotmail.com on Mon Dec 13 09:00:38 GMT 2021
Hi Ticker,
the unpatched SrtDisplay shows this table at the end, the patched version doesn't. Is that intended?
0008 prim=0,sec=0,tert=0
0009 prim=0,sec=0,tert=0
000a prim=0,sec=0,tert=0
000b prim=0,sec=0,tert=0
000c prim=0,sec=0,tert=0
000d prim=0,sec=0,tert=0
000e prim=0,sec=0,tert=0
000f prim=0,sec=0,tert=0
0010 prim=0,sec=0,tert=0
0011 prim=0,sec=0,tert=0
0012 prim=0,sec=0,tert=0
0013 prim=0,sec=0,tert=0
0014 prim=0,sec=0,tert=0
0015 prim=0,sec=0,tert=0
0016 prim=0,sec=0,tert=0
0017 prim=0,sec=0,tert=0
0018 prim=0,sec=0,tert=0
0019 prim=0,sec=0,tert=0
001a prim=0,sec=0,tert=0
001b prim=0,sec=0,tert=0
001c prim=0,sec=0,tert=0
001d prim=0,sec=0,tert=0
007f prim=0,sec=0,tert=0
? prim=0,sec=0,tert=0
? prim=0,sec=0,tert=0
? prim=0,sec=0,tert=0
? prim=0,sec=0,tert=0
? prim=0,sec=0,tert=0
? prim=0,sec=0,tert=0
? prim=0,sec=0,tert=0
0001 prim=0,sec=0,tert=8
0002 prim=0,sec=0,tert=9
0003 prim=0,sec=0,tert=10
0004 prim=0,sec=0,tert=11
0005 prim=0,sec=0,tert=12
0006 prim=0,sec=0,tert=13
0007 prim=0,sec=0,tert=14
0020 prim=3,sec=1,tert=1
00a0 prim=3,sec=1,tert=2
001e prim=3,sec=1,tert=3
001f prim=3,sec=1,tert=4
` prim=5,sec=1,tert=1
´ prim=6,sec=1,tert=1
˜ prim=7,sec=1,tert=1
^ prim=8,sec=1,tert=1
¯ prim=9,sec=1,tert=1
¨ prim=10,sec=1,tert=1
¸ prim=12,sec=1,tert=1
_ prim=14,sec=1,tert=1
00ad prim=15,sec=1,tert=1
- prim=16,sec=1,tert=1
– prim=17,sec=1,tert=1
— prim=18,sec=1,tert=1
002c prim=20,sec=1,tert=1
003b prim=26,sec=1,tert=1
: prim=28,sec=1,tert=1
! prim=30,sec=1,tert=1
¡ prim=31,sec=1,tert=1
? prim=33,sec=1,tert=1
¿ prim=35,sec=1,tert=1
. prim=38,sec=1,tert=1
· prim=41,sec=1,tert=1
' prim=45,sec=1,tert=1
‘ prim=46,sec=1,tert=1
’ prim=47,sec=1,tert=1
‚ prim=48,sec=1,tert=1
‹ prim=50,sec=1,tert=1
› prim=51,sec=1,tert=1
" prim=52,sec=1,tert=1
“ prim=53,sec=1,tert=1
” prim=54,sec=1,tert=1
„ prim=55,sec=1,tert=1
« prim=60,sec=1,tert=1
» prim=61,sec=1,tert=1
( prim=62,sec=1,tert=1
) prim=63,sec=1,tert=1
[ prim=64,sec=1,tert=1
] prim=65,sec=1,tert=1
{ prim=66,sec=1,tert=1
} prim=67,sec=1,tert=1
§ prim=94,sec=1,tert=1
¶ prim=95,sec=1,tert=1
© prim=96,sec=1,tert=1
® prim=97,sec=1,tert=1
@ prim=98,sec=1,tert=1
* prim=99,sec=1,tert=1
/ prim=101,sec=1,tert=1
\ prim=103,sec=1,tert=1
& prim=104,sec=1,tert=1
0023 prim=105,sec=1,tert=1
% prim=106,sec=1,tert=1
‰ prim=108,sec=1,tert=1
† prim=110,sec=1,tert=1
‡ prim=111,sec=1,tert=1
• prim=112,sec=1,tert=1
ˆ prim=114,sec=1,tert=1
° prim=115,sec=1,tert=1
+ prim=117,sec=1,tert=1
± prim=118,sec=1,tert=1
÷ prim=119,sec=1,tert=1
× prim=120,sec=1,tert=1
003c prim=121,sec=1,tert=1
003d prim=122,sec=1,tert=1
> prim=123,sec=1,tert=1
¬ prim=124,sec=1,tert=1
| prim=125,sec=1,tert=1
¦ prim=126,sec=1,tert=1
~ prim=127,sec=1,tert=1
¤ prim=129,sec=1,tert=1
¢ prim=130,sec=1,tert=1
$ prim=131,sec=1,tert=1
£ prim=132,sec=1,tert=1
¥ prim=133,sec=1,tert=1
€ prim=134,sec=1,tert=1
0 prim=136,sec=1,tert=1
1 prim=137,sec=1,tert=1
¹ prim=137,sec=1,tert=2
2 prim=138,sec=1,tert=1
² prim=138,sec=1,tert=2
3 prim=139,sec=1,tert=1
³ prim=139,sec=1,tert=2
4 prim=140,sec=1,tert=1
5 prim=141,sec=1,tert=1
6 prim=142,sec=1,tert=1
7 prim=143,sec=1,tert=1
8 prim=144,sec=1,tert=1
9 prim=145,sec=1,tert=1
a prim=147,sec=1,tert=1
A prim=147,sec=1,tert=2
ª prim=147,sec=1,tert=3
á prim=147,sec=2,tert=1
Á prim=147,sec=2,tert=2
à prim=147,sec=3,tert=1
À prim=147,sec=3,tert=2
â prim=147,sec=4,tert=1
 prim=147,sec=4,tert=2
å prim=147,sec=5,tert=1
Å prim=147,sec=5,tert=2
ä prim=147,sec=6,tert=1
Ä prim=147,sec=6,tert=2
ã prim=147,sec=7,tert=1
à prim=147,sec=7,tert=2
b prim=149,sec=1,tert=1
B prim=149,sec=1,tert=2
c prim=151,sec=1,tert=1
C prim=151,sec=1,tert=2
ç prim=151,sec=2,tert=1
Ç prim=151,sec=2,tert=2
d prim=153,sec=1,tert=1
D prim=153,sec=1,tert=2
e prim=156,sec=1,tert=1
E prim=156,sec=1,tert=2
é prim=156,sec=2,tert=1
É prim=156,sec=2,tert=2
è prim=156,sec=3,tert=1
È prim=156,sec=3,tert=2
ê prim=156,sec=4,tert=1
Ê prim=156,sec=4,tert=2
ë prim=156,sec=5,tert=1
Ë prim=156,sec=5,tert=2
f prim=158,sec=1,tert=1
F prim=158,sec=1,tert=2
ƒ prim=159,sec=1,tert=1
g prim=161,sec=1,tert=1
G prim=161,sec=1,tert=2
ğ prim=161,sec=2,tert=1
Ğ prim=161,sec=2,tert=2
h prim=163,sec=1,tert=1
H prim=163,sec=1,tert=2
i prim=165,sec=1,tert=1
I prim=165,sec=1,tert=2
í prim=165,sec=2,tert=1
Í prim=165,sec=2,tert=2
ì prim=165,sec=3,tert=1
Ì prim=165,sec=3,tert=2
î prim=165,sec=4,tert=1
Î prim=165,sec=4,tert=2
ï prim=165,sec=5,tert=1
Ï prim=165,sec=5,tert=2
ı prim=166,sec=1,tert=1
İ prim=166,sec=6,tert=2
j prim=167,sec=1,tert=1
J prim=167,sec=1,tert=2
k prim=169,sec=1,tert=1
K prim=169,sec=1,tert=2
l prim=170,sec=1,tert=1
L prim=170,sec=1,tert=2
m prim=172,sec=1,tert=1
M prim=172,sec=1,tert=2
n prim=174,sec=1,tert=1
N prim=174,sec=1,tert=2
Ñ prim=174,sec=2,tert=1
ñ prim=174,sec=2,tert=1
o prim=177,sec=1,tert=1
O prim=177,sec=1,tert=2
º prim=177,sec=1,tert=3
ó prim=177,sec=2,tert=1
Ó prim=177,sec=2,tert=2
ò prim=177,sec=3,tert=1
Ò prim=177,sec=3,tert=2
ô prim=177,sec=4,tert=1
Ô prim=177,sec=4,tert=2
ö prim=177,sec=5,tert=1
Ö prim=177,sec=5,tert=2
õ prim=177,sec=6,tert=1
Õ prim=177,sec=6,tert=2
ø prim=177,sec=7,tert=1
Ø prim=177,sec=7,tert=2
p prim=182,sec=1,tert=1
P prim=182,sec=1,tert=2
q prim=184,sec=1,tert=1
Q prim=184,sec=1,tert=2
r prim=186,sec=1,tert=1
R prim=186,sec=1,tert=2
s prim=189,sec=1,tert=1
S prim=189,sec=1,tert=2
š prim=189,sec=4,tert=1
Š prim=189,sec=4,tert=2
ş prim=189,sec=6,tert=1
Ş prim=189,sec=6,tert=2
t prim=193,sec=1,tert=1
T prim=193,sec=1,tert=2
u prim=196,sec=1,tert=1
U prim=196,sec=1,tert=2
ú prim=196,sec=2,tert=1
Ú prim=196,sec=2,tert=2
ù prim=196,sec=3,tert=1
Ù prim=196,sec=3,tert=2
û prim=196,sec=4,tert=1
Û prim=196,sec=4,tert=2
ü prim=196,sec=5,tert=1
Ü prim=196,sec=5,tert=2
v prim=199,sec=1,tert=1
V prim=199,sec=1,tert=2
w prim=201,sec=1,tert=1
W prim=201,sec=1,tert=2
x prim=202,sec=1,tert=1
X prim=202,sec=1,tert=2
y prim=205,sec=1,tert=1
Y prim=205,sec=1,tert=2
ÿ prim=205,sec=2,tert=1
Ÿ prim=205,sec=2,tert=2
z prim=207,sec=1,tert=1
Z prim=207,sec=1,tert=2
µ prim=210,sec=1,tert=1
________________________________________
Von: mkgmap-dev <mkgmap-dev-bounces at lists.mkgmap.org.uk> im Auftrag von Ticker Berkin <rwb-mkgmap at jagit.co.uk>
Gesendet: Sonntag, 12. Dezember 2021 14:01
An: Development list for mkgmap
Betreff: Re: [mkgmap-dev] Error in MdrCheck?
Hi Gerd
I've had a go at display SrdDisplay so it reproduces output close to
the mkgmap resource/sort/cp*.txt files
Patch attached
I've also attached the output from the Turkish 00000848.SRT you sent
and there are quite a few differences from ours. We should consider
what to do with the version numbering (id2 I presume).
There is something in the expansion flags that appears to control which
secondary/tertiary variant should be selected and I haven't bothered
with this.
Ticker
On Fri, 2021-12-10 at 13:37 +0000, Gerd Petermann wrote:
> Hi Ticker,
>
> attached is the extracted *.srt.
> The original link to the turkey download posted here no longer works:
> https://www.mkgmap.org.uk/pipermail/mkgmap-dev/2017q2/026715.html
>
>
> Gerd
>
> ________________________________________
> Von: mkgmap-dev <mkgmap-dev-bounces at lists.mkgmap.org.uk> im Auftrag
> von Ticker Berkin <rwb-mkgmap at jagit.co.uk>
> Gesendet: Freitag, 10. Dezember 2021 10:37
> An: Development list for mkgmap
> Betreff: Re: [mkgmap-dev] Error in MdrCheck?
>
> Hi Gerd
>
> Working on the basis of guessing and resources/sort/README, we
> shouldn't use the same id2 if our sort is different to one from
> Garmin
> (or elsewhere). A device will have a base-map that defines the sort
> it
> needs, represented by id1/id2. Addition maps shouldn't use the same
> pair to represent a different sort. Maybe we should change id2 for
> all
> our maps to be some arbitrary higher number, or certainly do this
> when
> a conflict is spotted.
>
> Looking at the SrtDisplay "Summary of ordering" output, it should be
> possible to hack the code a bit or edit the output to get back to
> what
> our sort tables look like. Assuming as the ? problem can be fixed,
> the
> significant question is what is the meaning of the lowest sortOrder.
> In
> our tables, everything before the first "<" gets zero and doesn't
> contribute to the ordering, along with anything not defined.
> SrtDisplay
> puts everything after the first "<".
>
> Can you sent me the Turkish .SRT subfile and I'll have a look.
>
> Ticker
>
>
> On Fri, 2021-12-10 at 08:15 +0000, Gerd Petermann wrote:
> > Hi Ticker,
> >
> > Both have the same ids:
> > 00000044 | 000002 | 0e 00 | id1 14
> > 00000046 | 000004 | 01 00 | id2 1
> > 00000048 | 000006 | e6 04 | codepage 1254
> >
> > reg. SrtDisplay:
> > Our file looks very different compared to the "Summary of ordering"
> > report. I don't understand most of the details, and for sure I
> > don't
> > know which one is better.
> > I think the summary cannot be used as input for mkgmap because it
> > contains several '?' where characters coulnd't be converted to
> > unicode.
> > (same problem when I create a map with --codepage=1252 and use
> > SrtDisplay on that.
> >
> > Gerd
> >
> > ________________________________________
> > Von: mkgmap-dev <mkgmap-dev-bounces at lists.mkgmap.org.uk> im Auftrag
> > von Ticker Berkin <rwb-mkgmap at jagit.co.uk>
> > Gesendet: Donnerstag, 9. Dezember 2021 12:51
> > An: Development list for mkgmap
> > Betreff: Re: [mkgmap-dev] Error in MdrCheck?
> >
> > Hi Gerd
> >
> > The alternative would be to use test.display.SrtDisplay to generate
> > a
> > different version of our resources/sort/cp1254.txt that matches
> > theirs, or maybe have versions findable by id1/id2 that match.
> >
> > Ticker
> >
> >
> > On Thu, 2021-12-09 at 09:09 +0000, Gerd Petermann wrote:
> > > Hi devs,
> > >
> > > I think there is a bug in MdrCheck, probably also in other Check
> > > programs. The program doesn't read the SRT file content from the
> > > map,
> > > instead it uses the corresponding data from mkgmap.
> > > If the builtin sort order in mkgmap doesn't match the SRT file
> > > content the program will report errors about wrong order or
> > > missing
> > > repeat flags etc.
> > > I guess this explains why MdrCheck complains about the Garmin
> > > demo
> > > map for Turkey?
> > >
> > > I once started to implement a SrtFileReader but I don't know if
> > > that
> > > can be used instead.
> > >
> > > Gerd
> > >
> > >
> > > _______________________________________________
> > > mkgmap-dev mailing list
> > > mkgmap-dev at lists.mkgmap.org.uk
> > > https://www.mkgmap.org.uk/mailman/listinfo/mkgmap-dev
> >
> >
> > _______________________________________________
> > mkgmap-dev mailing list
> > mkgmap-dev at lists.mkgmap.org.uk
> > https://www.mkgmap.org.uk/mailman/listinfo/mkgmap-dev
> > _______________________________________________
> > mkgmap-dev mailing list
> > mkgmap-dev at lists.mkgmap.org.uk
> > https://www.mkgmap.org.uk/mailman/listinfo/mkgmap-dev
>
>
> _______________________________________________
> mkgmap-dev mailing list
> mkgmap-dev at lists.mkgmap.org.uk
> https://www.mkgmap.org.uk/mailman/listinfo/mkgmap-dev
> _______________________________________________
> mkgmap-dev mailing list
> mkgmap-dev at lists.mkgmap.org.uk
> https://www.mkgmap.org.uk/mailman/listinfo/mkgmap-dev
- Previous message: [mkgmap-dev] Error in MdrCheck?
- Next message: [mkgmap-dev] Error in MdrCheck?
- Messages sorted by: [ date ] [ thread ] [ subject ] [ author ]
More information about the mkgmap-dev mailing list