[mkgmap-dev] short arcs demystified, please try value 0

Sat Oct 5 15:19:51 BST 2013

Hi Gerd

> > I couldnt find any specific routing bugs that were solved but I
> > didnt see any differences in routing with previous mkgmap versions
> > either.
> Thanks for testing :-)
> Does that mean you find routing errors with value 0 that you cannot
> explain with the OSM input data? If yes, d like to reproduce them.

No I meant I couldnt find any routing errors besides the already known bugs (see below)
but they seems not have anything to do with short arcs.
So, as far as I have tested remove-short-arcs=0 seems to work fine.

> > One particular routing error that still bugs me is that pedestrians
> > can't cross tile borders (Basecamp) unless toll roads are avoided.
> > In all other vehicle profiles this bug is only triggered when
> > interstate highways are avoided. When toll road avoidance is active
> > the routing is ok. Tested with the default style on Lambertus' maps.
> 
> Is that the same problem that was discussed here?
> http://gis.19327.n5.nabble.com/Basecamp-4-2-2-Inter-tile-routing-problem-tp5772247.html

> I have no idea how to work on this :-(

Yes, same problem.