[mkgmap-dev] Some bounderies shown as river

Thu Oct 7 19:03:02 BST 2010

Am 07.10.2010 18:08, schrieb Torsten Leistikow:
> Josef Latt schrieb am 07.10.2010 11:23:
>> one of the river (tracks Rhein) where the boundaries, shown as river,
>> starts has two ways. One with tag boundary and waterway=river, the other
>> only with waterway=river.
> 
> I don't understand your problem. When the way ist tagged as boundary and as
> river at the same time, you shouldn't be surprised, when this is displayed as a
> river. So right now this sounds to me like a mapping error and not like a mkgmap
> problem.

That means that a tagging like this is false?

<?xml version="1.0"?>
<osm generator="Merkaartor 0.16" version="0.6">
  <node version="1" lon="7.43785560" lat="50.22632410"
timestamp="2010-04-07T20:32:23Z" user="bundesrainer" id="687862342"
actor="2"/>
  <way version="2" timestamp="2010-06-22T11:26:11Z" user="Geogast"
id="54643300" actor="2">
    <nd ref="687862342"/>
    <nd ref="298275173"/>
    <nd ref="301913638"/>
    <tag k="admin_level" v="8"/>
    <tag k="boundary" v="administrative"/>
    <tag k="history" v="Retrieved from v8"/>
    <tag k="name" v="Mosel"/>
    <tag k="name:de" v="Mosel"/>
    <tag k="name:es" v="Mosela"/>
    <tag k="name:fr" v="Moselle"/>
    <tag k="note" v="MapFeatures suggest to have waterway=river in
additon to waterway=riverbank, this is why its here"/>
    <tag k="waterway" v="river"/>
  </way>
  <node version="16" lon="7.44285940" lat="50.22731440"
timestamp="2009-03-05T17:08:14Z" user="KK-O" id="298275173" actor="2"/>
  <node version="14" lon="7.44647270" lat="50.22997290"
timestamp="2009-03-05T17:08:14Z" user="KK-O" id="301913638" actor="2"/>
  <bound box="50.226324,7.437856,50.229973,7.446473"
origin="http://www.openstreetmap.org/api/0.6"/>
</osm>

But, why mkgmap-r1625 doesn't have this bug and why show other similar
tags down the Mosel no boundaries as river?

Greetings
Josef